Taste

Flavors & Dietary Options

Cake flavors, fillings, and frostings are customized to every order, including vegan, gluten-free, eggless, sugar-free, and organic versions.

Cake flavors and fillings at CMNY Cakes

Custom flavors

Our cake flavors and fillings

In each cake tier there are four layers of cake and three layers of filling, so every slice is moist and full of flavor. Each tier can be its own flavor and filling, though most keep one flavor throughout. Many of our flavors and fillings are available in vegan or eggless versions.

Cake flavors

Four layers of cake in every tier.

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Dense chocolate
  • Red velvet
  • Marble swirl
  • Almond
  • Pistachio
  • Lemon

Fillings

Three layers of filling between the cake layers.

  • Vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream
  • Chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream
  • Cream cheese buttercream
  • White chocolate buttercream
  • Salted caramel buttercream
  • Nutella (chocolate hazelnut) buttercream
  • Cookies and cream buttercream (Oreo)
  • Raspberry buttercream
  • Strawberry buttercream
  • Lemon curd buttercream
  • Cannoli filling buttercream
  • Chocolate mousse

Have a flavor you love that is not on the list? Ask us. We work with seasonal and custom combinations too.

Dietary options

We have perfected recipes for a range of dietary needs, available for most cake orders:

Vegan

Egg- and dairy-free recipes without compromising on texture.

Gluten-free

Gluten-free cakes for celebrations of any size.

Eggless

Egg-free options for dietary and preference needs.

Sugar-free

Reduced- and no-sugar recipes on request.

Organic

Organic-ingredient cakes available.

Ask us

Have a specific requirement? Tell us and we will advise.

Start your cake

Get a quote

Tell us your design, your event date, and your guest count. We reply within one business day with pricing and availability.

Cakes start at $8 / slice, with a $250 minimum per cake. 3D cakes start at $500. Most orders need at least one week; two to three weeks is best for custom designs.
Have a design in mind? Attach a photo or two and we will work from it. You can add more photos one at a time, and remove any before sending.

Prefer email? Attach inspiration photos to a note to info@cmnycakes.com.